You are here:   Community > Forums
Register   |  Login
 
Getting There From Here Community ForumsGetting There From Here Community ForumsColonizationColonizationExtrasolar Plan...Extrasolar Plan...Gravity: How Much Is Too Much?Gravity: How Much Is Too Much?
Disabled 
Previous
 
Next Next
New Post
 12/21/2009 10:16 PM
 
Given that our scientists keep finding more and more large planets (those being the easiest to find), including some that may be in the habitable zone for their stars, I have to ask the question: how much gravity is too much? Could humans adapt to live on a planet with twice Earth's gravity? Four times? Eight? What about with genetic engineering?

Just as importantly (or possibly more so), even if we could survive there, is it reasonable to colonize? What I'm basically asking here is, would we be able to take off again if we landed there? On a planet with twice the gravity of Earth, a rocket would require a ridiculous amount of fuel just to reach orbit. A space elevator (with our current estimates of strengths of materials) would be impossible.

How much is too much?
New Post
 3/16/2010 11:14 AM
 
Considering that there are animals that have adapted to high pressure depths in our oceans, I would be very surprised if we could engineer ourselves to take advantage of higher gravity worlds (within reason). Given the advancement of human prosthesis, this is enhanced even more.
New Post
 6/14/2010 12:33 PM
 

While I generally agree that technological advances will increase our abilities to operate in more varied environments, in this case I think it is important to recognize the difference between higher gravities and higher pressures. Each poses unique challenges that will require different and specialized engineering solutions. Likewise, with regard the topic of Pressure, we need to consider the challenges posed not only by higher pressures, but lower pressures as well. That said, the same goes for gravities.

Really, this topic is two questions:

1. What gravity and pressure ranges are feasible for a) entry into an environment or b) exit from an environment; and what is required for each

2. What gravity and pressure ranges are feasible for a) human life b) augmented human life; and what is required for each

The same questions need to be asked of all Support Systems. The responses to those questions help to determine mission parameters (Requirements.) All that aside, perhaps there are some doctors, physiologists, physicists, etc. that we could tap for this (now that we have the Project Manager perspective.)

New Post
 6/22/2010 9:23 PM
 
Good points, humanferret. My point was more along the lines of usefulness to a space-going civilization, which would mean being able to land and take off again. ValiantRose seemed to be looking more at the ability to survive there. Those really are two different points, and both useful questions to ask.

I think it's safe to say that useful to a spacefaring civilization is more restrictive than safe to live on. We can probably adapt (either evolutionarily or through bio-engineering) to survive on a planet, but if we can't get off the surface once we're there, I think we'd be better off living under pressure domes on a moon somewhere.
Disabled 
Previous
 
Next Next
Getting There From Here Community ForumsGetting There From Here Community ForumsColonizationColonizationExtrasolar Plan...Extrasolar Plan...Gravity: How Much Is Too Much?Gravity: How Much Is Too Much?

Share this page - email email | delicious.com delicious.com | digg digg | technorati technorati | reddit reddit | stumbleupon stumbleupon | facebook facebook | newsvine newsvine | simpy simpy | google bookmarks google bookmarks | yahoo bookmarks yahoo bookmarks | yahoo myweb yahoo myweb | ask ask | slashdot slashdot | rawsugar rawsugar | mister-wong mister-wong | backflip backflip | diigo diigo | tailrank tailrank | live live | twitter twitter | fark fark | blogmarks blogmarks | linkagogo linkagogo | wink wink | ma.gnolia ma.gnolia | bluedot bluedot | netvouz netvouz | blinklist blinklist | sphinn sphinn

Copyright ©2010 Getting There From Here Hosted by Advanced Hosting Solutions